Devonthink vs Bookends

Sure.

It starts with me searching for journal articles using Google Scholar or my DEVONagent search sets. When I find an article I want, I clip it to Zotero using that browser plug-in. Now I have the PDF and all the metadata needed to cite the article in a manuscript:


In the background, two things happen:

  1. Hazel recognizes that a new PDF was added to Zotero and runs Zowie on it to add the Zotero link to the PDF.
  2. My Zotero database is indexed in DEVONthink, so the PDF shows up over there in my smart group to read.

Screen Shot 2022-01-02 at 10.06.03 AM
Screen Shot 2022-01-02 at 10.06.29 AM

I then read and annotate the article in DEVONthink. Those markups show up for me whether I am in DT or Zotero, since it’s the same file. I can create collections of references in Zotero, or use DT’s AI and search features to find connections between articles.

Screen Shot 2022-01-02 at 10.32.19 AM

When I am ready to write, I used LibreOffice with Zotero’s citation tools installed (I can do the same in Word, but prefer LO):

Screen Shot 2022-01-02 at 10.13.21 AM
image

I can write something, quickly add the citation which is automatically formatted and added to the works cited page:

As I edit and rewrite, Zotero manages the citations, making sure that everything is formatted correctly and if I add or remove an in-text citation the works cited is automatically updated. And if I need to submit to a journal that requires a different style, Modern Humanities Research Association, for example, it’s three clicks:

I get to use each app for what it’s best at, but all using the same PDF.

EDITED TO ADD:

Oh, and I can be at work on a Windows machine, find an article I need, clip it to Zotero there and it syncs to my Mac at home and all this just happens…

9 Likes