I also agree with the opinions expressed here. I was writing a long message about the topic to send privately explaining some things, but it seems I’m not the only one who thinks the same way. As a beta tester, I didn’t have the opportunity to test this before the product launch, mostly due to a lack of time.
Aside from the problems mentioned around here, and although some are just a matter of getting used to the new interface, I really do miss the option to press with the Apple Pencil or select text and have a context menu appear to automatically underline or annotate. Not having that threw me off a lot, especially since the original SDK (at least in the manufacturer’s own PDF Viewer version) still maintains that interface. In fact, if we have text selected and the edit menu opens and the underline or highlight button is tapped, the action should be executed on the selected text. That is what one would expect.
But there are more problems I haven’t read about here: thanks to the Apple *Ass, the usable part of the screen is even smaller than before. The document going underneath the toolbars is very pretty but completely useless in terms of usability, especially since if you have the document in full screen, there are margins left around it that make a bad situation worse, which is that the menu bar is always fixed and doesn’t allow for full-screen ‘real estate.’ In my case, it’s enough to make me leave the manageable 11-inch iPad and have to work with the 13-inch one, and I don’t want to think about how bad that will look on the Mini. In fact, in my case, DTTG is currently a no-go for PDF management, which is 90% of the use I give it. For now, I’m getting by opening the file with PDF Viewer via the file manager and then going back to DTTG for synchronization. And that’s something that pisses me off because, having been able to detect that in the beta, I didn’t do it because I barely used it.
I think the ‘real estate’ problem should be solved as soon as possible.
And related to that, there is another thing that frustrates me a lot, and that is the inadvertent taps above the toolbar, which launch the PDF to the first page and then, in theory, if you tap again, take you back to the previous position, but—ah, my friend!—you have to be lucky enough to get it right the first time or else, well, start searching manually for the previous position, which isn’t much of a problem with a 10-page PDF, but it is with a 300-page one. Sometimes you have the little back arrow underneath, but other times not, and as far as I remember, not when you tap in the forbidden area.
Seriously, Erik, disable that or put in an option to disable it. In fact, for several builds now, that hasn’t worked in the SDK manufacturer’s reference App. You can’t even imagine how frustrating it is to have that happen when you’re concentrated on your things, and even more so if you can’t easily get back to where you were.
And one very minor thing that I personally liked a lot: the rounded edges in text highlighting. It’s childish, it’s inconsequential, but many times I kept using DTTG with PDFs just for that.