I can’t get ProQuest (PQ) sourced articles to download into DT for reading and annotating.
After easily adding non-PQ sourced PDFs and an hour of trying everything I can think of to get PQ to do the same, all that sticks in DT is a link to the article in PQ, but not the article itself for me to work with.
As I have success with accessing non-PQ sources, and I am new to using DT this way, I don’t know if this is operator error or on PQ’s end (yes, I accessed PQ’s libguides hoping to find an answer but no luck).
I was able to add the bookmark which just took me back to ProQuest and the same issue.
I thought to check my library’s listing and found other sources besides ProQuest for this one. I was able to import it into DT from one of those. Issue solved and, bonus, I have learned not to use ProQuest with DT.
Have you got an example of one of the items you were having trouble with?
Also, are we talking about downloading a PDF of an academic paper or trying to save a webpage (I think for paywalled newspapers, for example, they present the content in the webpage?)?
I looked out of interest and downloading a PDF works fine for me (no different to other websites) and I thought I’d ask before trying to test something else. I suspect that “save as PDF” button for newspapers is a little tricky as it looks like it’s a pop-up.
I download articles all the time from ProQuest and have never experienced problems, but it sounds as if you’re attempting a more sophisticated workflow than mine. I simply download PDFs from ProQuest in Safari to an indexed folder in DT, using the in-browser download button; is the difference that you’re trying to download from the DT in-app browser? I can see that the ProQuest download button code might not run in that.
First, I don’t think there’s anything sophisticated here. I’m totally new to all this (hence my “issues”). Because of that newness, to your point, I may be complicating things. It sounds, to me, like I’m doing as you outline, but I may be missing something.
Yes, I am in PQ via Safari; the PQ article is on my screen. You then say, “I simply download PDFs from ProQuest in Safari to an indexed folder in DT, using the in-browser download button.” I may be lost here: I’m at PQ, article in front of me; I hit “Download” (on the screen) and the article/file shows up in my downloads folder. I open that file and it is now open in Adobe Acrobat (PDF reader) which does me no good (I want it in DT). So I go back to the downloads folder and drag the file/article into DT. I try to open it, ie I click on the newly created DT entry, and all it does is take me back to PQ. I can’t get it to open in DT for reading and annotating.
Instead of hitting the article’s download button I tried saving it to DT using the “Clip to DEVONthink” browser extension; same result.
Any ideas?
Could it be that some authors, using PQ, put a “do not download” on their work while others don’t? My assumption is it would be a PQ policy, site wide, one way or the other.
When I have a PDF in the Safari browser window, I often/usually simply do a Safari Menu → File → Save as… and direct the files to the DEVONthink Global Inbox. Don’t bother with any download buttons or the DEVONthink Sorter. I check that it worked, and if not, do something else–but it usually works.
Thanks for clarifying; I think I see the issue now. To view the PDF in DT, you need to switch to DT and view it from within DT. Double-clicking on it in the Finder will simply open it in your default PDF app (in this case, Acrobat Reader).
If your Downloads folder is an indexed folder in DT, just switch to DT after downloading, and you’ll be able to view and move the file to wherever you want to store it, as well as double-clicking on the file (in DT) to open it in its own DT window. If you don’t have the Downloads folder indexed in DT, you’ll need instead to move it into a DT database or the Global Inbox from the Finder (or into a Finder folder that’s indexed in DT).
A useful consequence of indexing the Downloads folder is that files newly downloaded there will show up in the built-in Today Smart Group, which you can add to Favourites for quick access to a list of recently added or edited files.
You say, “To view the PDF in DT, you need to switch to DT and view it from within DT. Double-clicking on it in the Finder will simply open it in your default PDF app (in this case, Acrobat Reader).” I am in DT; I double click on its entry “line” in DT (top of the centre section on my screen).
“If your Downloads folder is an indexed folder in DT…” I can find my Downloads folder on my Mac; In DT I don’t see a Downloads folder; I do see Inboxes but nothing that says Downloads so I’m not sure what this part means.
“… after downloading… you’ll be able to view and move the file to wherever you want to store it, as well as double-clicking on the file (in DT) to open it in its own DT window.” Yes, I go to the DT Global Inbox and drag the file to the appropriate Database Group. I then double-click the file, in DT, and yes, it opens in its own DT window. With you. This is what I’m doing and the PDF doesn’t open, just a link back to ProQuest opens.
But what is new to me is “indexing the Downloads folder.” If I understand your last para, it sounds like another way to access files instead of the Global Inbox, ie they’re going to the Today Smart Group instead of the Global Inbox. I’m not clear on how this will help with my PDF problem.
You need to setup a Finder alias pointing to the Global Inbox, and it will be called “Inbox”. It’s described in the DEVONthink Manual… not at hand right now to point to it for you, but take a look.
A screenshot can say more an a thousand words. And avoid misunderstandings.
That’s why the sentence began with an “If”. If you did not index your download folder (and only you can now if you did or didn’t), than you will not see it in DT. Did I mention that the manual included with DT (accessible via the Help menu) explains many things and is worth studying? It also explains the difference between indexing and importing.
Screenshot. Says more than a thousand words. If you’re redirected to a website, chances are that you never saved a PDF but only a link.
Many thanks; your screenshot is very helpful (visual learner here).
And yes, as I answered on your previous suggestion of this, I have read parts of the manual word for word. I did not read, and cannot retain, every word of every part outside of a need for application. I realize it is there for these kinds of questions but I have not found an intuitive/logical way to search for and find what I need when I need it.
Yes, I do have the “Taking Control…” book, which, thankfully, is navigable. And, sometimes, conversing in community, one provided for just these reasons is, for me, a preferable choice. Connection. People helping people. One of life’s very good things, imho.
While that is true, you should also make it as easy as possible for these people to help you. And visual cues are an important part of that. You being a visual learner …
If it is already there, than it will appear in the Finder window opening when you select “Save as…” in your browser. It does here, in any case. So, you can save from your browser to this inbox and then the saved file will magically appear in DT.
But the quesion remains: what exactly is saved. If you see a PDF in your browser, I think that should arrive in DT. But from your previous posts, it doesn’t look like that. Perhaps if you posted a screenshot of the inspector view (ride sidebar) with this file selected in DT…
Sorry, I should have been clearer – I meant double-clicking on the file icon in the list view (left-hand item in screenshot below), just as you’d double-click on an icon in the Finder to open it. If you instead click on the centre of the Preview window toolbar, DT will try to open the source URL that is part of the file’s metadata – in this case, the original ProQuest page. (You can verify that this has been saved with the file by looking in the URL field of the Generic inspector.)
(It may also be worth checking, as @chrillek suggests, that what you’ve downloaded is indeed the actual PDF – it’ll show as PDF+Text in the View panel.)
It’s part of DT’s Finder-substitute functionality. If a Finder folder is indexed in an open DT database, you can access that folder from within DT and move things around just as in the Finder, with some additional enhancements like replicants, the Move popover, and moving/copying between databases. It may or may not suit your workflow, but it makes something like the Downloads folder available within DT itself, which means among other things that DT Smart Groups can be used to locate recently-added items.